Level Designer

BLOG

Level Studies: Wild Animals

WARNING: MAJOR STORY AND ENDING SPOILERS AHEAD


INTRODUCTION


With this series, I desire to study and recreate my favorite levels. Inspired by the work of Michael Barclay and Ovidiu Mantoc in learning by recreating, the following is the first in a series of studies that I hope to learn and grow from.

The following summary and various terminology is based on a variety of interviews, documentaries and lectures by Peter Field, Emilia Schatz, Neil Druckmann, Richard Cambier, Bruce Straley, Kurt Margenau and the amazing team at Naughty Dog. All credit the team, past and present, at Naughty Dog.

As a final warning, story and ending spoilers ahead.

wild-blog-a.jpg

story, beats and starting out


In the Last of Us, the chapter “Spring” (code name “Wild Animals”) finds Joel and Ellie finally arriving in Salt Lake City, Utah where they hope to find the Fireflies at St. Mary’s Hospital. The skeletal beats of this level as described by designer Peter Field:

  • Ellie is visibly detached

  • Ellie is brought back to life with the sight of the giraffe

  • Big, culminating infected fight

  • Co-operative puzzle reminding the player of Ellie’s inability to swim

  • Joel becomes trapped and about to drown

  • Ellie risks her life to rescue Joel by jumping into the water

  • Joel rescues an unconscious Ellie

These beats set the structure for the level and help define what the player is feeling moment to moment. Upon dissecting this level’s beats, you realize the depth of storytelling involved as we grow closer to the conclusion. This map not only explores the next chapter of Ellie and Joel’s relationship—beat by beat—but crafts much of the experience to be playable through mechanics and therein keeping the player connected to what impending events may be next.


“Spring” starts with Ellie looking at a decorative carving of a deer in the highway wall. This moment calls back to the deer that opens up with “Winter”. To revisit, the “Winter” section ends with Joel and Ellie narrowly escaping an encounter with a barbaric clan and their leader David. The horror of this encounter leaves a sense for how dark this world has become. This has left Ellie detached, disturbed and forever changed. The brutal killing of David to defend herself is a key moment for Ellie. Not only did she care completely for Joel in the absence of his health, she defended herself, without the help of Joel. In this dark moment, we see how completely capable Ellie is to defend herself and those she loves. This intense moment for both Ellie and the player, however, takes a toll. We see the emotional ramifications of all these actions as we open on “Spring.”

With a clever use of sound editing, performances, environment art, animation and camera work, we feel Ellie “zoning” out as she stares beyond the deer on the wall. Joel calls and regains her focus for just a moment to keep her moving ahead as the two descend upon Salt Lake City and the hopeful location of the Fireflies.

Beat Reminder: Ellie is visibly detached

The player is led forward by the linear highway with narrative moments given to interact with Ellie. Through the dialogue mechanic, the player is given the ability to speak with Ellie to try and understand what she is thinking and going through. We see Joel try to inject conversation and life back into Ellie. Where early in the game Joel may have been cold to Ellie, we can see him here try to be empathetic and bring hope back into Ellie—telling her that someday soon he will teach her to play guitar. These are deep, impactful moments that certainly I will never forget. The vulnerability of Joel throughout this level is reflected in the openness of the spaces throughout this level. Like Spring itself, this level is a point of change for both Ellie and Joel.

Below I tried to recreate some of the spaces within Maya to understand the ideas of scale and composition for this first space:


Compositions and Shapes


The level is a great example of leading the player intuitively through shapes and compositions. In her CG Master Academy course Level Design for Games, Emilia Schatz touches on the push and pull of a space. The angle of the vehicles, and framing created by various buildings. The freeway itself, when closely examined, is nicely rotated 10-15 degrees compared to side streets, buildings and bus station.

This level also exhibits some aspects of wide-linearity along the freeway and underpass. As shown below, the design allows the player to find exploratory spaces while being flowed back into the intended path. The player is rewarded appropriately for exploring the space.

As we come off the freeway, we find more space for exploration but, more importantly, the shapes begin to frame the goal for this chapter.

Everything is purposefully placed by the designers, environment art and lighting artists. In following video, Peter Field discusses working with artists on the composition and framing entering the Bus Station.

CLICK FOR VIDEO

Peter Field discusses the composition and framing entering the Bus Station.


Story Told Through Mechanics


This level eventually leads to one of my favorite parts within the entire game. As Ellie and Joel make their way off the freeway and into an abandoned bus station we see Ellie completely detached from the present. Using core mechanics and story, we experience this beautiful moment where the rhythm of gameplay we have come to know up to this point is completely subverted.

For a deeper dive into building rhythms in gameplay please check out Steve Gaynor’s fantastic podcast Tone Control w/ Episode 22 featuring Last of Us Co-Creator Bruce Straley.

Joel is trying to make his way forward through the bus station and into St. Mary’s Hospital, as framed in the previous space. He approaches a ladder with a common prompt the player has seen repeatedly across the game to boost Ellie. However, this time, Ellie does not come. The camera turns to show Ellie sitting at a nearby bench—her mind still processing all that had happened during Winter. With a small verbal nudge, Ellie slowly makes her way to be boosted up by Joel. Suddenly, she sees something on the second level and drops the ladder to Joel’s feet. The player is left having to pick up and place the ladder themselves, then hurriedly find where Ellie has ran off to—confusion, worry and curiosity all fall over Joel and the player.

Narrative and mechanics can elevate each other.
— Peter Field, Designer on "Spring"

This entire sequence could have been done using an in-game cutscene, however the designers at Naughty Dog thoughtfully kept all of this, as they would say, “on the stick.” A clever use of building a rhythm within the player then subverting that rhythm in a way that is completely and carefully tied to the narrative. It is extremely effective and a perfect example of tying core mechanics and story. As former Naughty Dog game designer Peter Field theorizes, “narrative and mechanics can elevate each other.”

CLICK FOR VIDEO

Neil Druckmann, Ashley Johnson and Troy Baker discuss this scene of using narrative and mechanics together.

As the player makes their way up the ladder to search out Ellie, we see her at the end of the room. In a reversal of roles, Ellie now urges us to come follow her. There is a spark of curiosity that pulls both Joel and the player to eagerly follow. The light beams brightly now.

Throughout this space we see the subtle and thoughtful arrangement of lines, shapes and props: the lines from the beams of sun point us along, the clutter of props arranged with lines that direct us to Ellie, and cracks in the window hint at the narrative and aesthetic reward awaiting them. Like the chink in the “Wall” during A Midsummer Night’s Dream, the player is teased with a reward on the other side.

Then, Joel and the player turn a corner and into a doorway. We see a beautiful giraffe freely roaming the world without the walls of the zoo that once bound it. We are witnessing life, free and abundant. As the the player uses the prompt to touch the giraffe we can feel the change in both ourselves and the characters.

Beat Reminder: “Ellie is brought back to life with the sight of the giraffe.”

The giraffe takes a moment and makes its way to the herd awaiting. Ellie turns to follow it and eagerly urges us to hurry and follow.

As we follow her, we enter a darkly lit stairwell to a slightly cracked door. We open the door to a large reveal of abundant light and life—it is Spring.

Using value, spatial and lighting contrast, the stairwell/doorway opening provides a great moment of compression and release upon the player.

I will never forget this moment and the thoughtful design. I felt not only a connection to the characters but deep release within my own heart and mind. I remember crying freely at this point.

In this final moment, a weight feels lifted. I believe because of this, Ellie feels reaffirmed of her goal to make it to the fireflies—she begins to hope again. Ellie reaffirms to Joel her choice to continue ahead no matter the danger. Ellie reminds us how incredibly fearless and selfless she is for the things and people she loves. This leads and prepares the player for the final trials before their ultimate goal.


Final Trials and Saying Goodbye


As we leave the bus station, the player has given space to breathe and scavenge for supplies in old, nearby triage stations. This is a nicely paced moment before the final combat encounter with the infected: the start to a series of goodbyes for both mechanics and enemy types. The designers thoughtfully place our fight with the infected first; fittingly leaving the interactions between the Fireflies and—more importantly—Joel and Ellie for last.

Beat Reminder: Big, culminating infected fight

This appropriately turns the focus to both Ellie and Joel and their relationship as we work together on the final puzzles of the game. Through these final challenges, we are once again reminded of Ellie’s inability to swim and the danger water presents to her. This is a carefully designed segment that again pairs narrative and mechanics to set up next crucial scene.

Beat Reminder: Co-operative puzzle reminding the player of Ellie’s inability to swim

CLICK FOR VIDEO

Peter Field breaking down the final puzzle design for the level.

Joel becomes trapped and about to drown

Ellie risks her life to rescue Joel by jumping into the water

Joel rescues an unconscious Ellie

In one last jump out of the sewers, Joel falls and becomes trapped in a bus now raging through the water. Without hesitating, Ellie jumps to his rescue but herself overtaken by the roaring water. Pairing the previous series of puzzles designed around water and the danger it presents to Ellie, the designers create a strong connection between the needs of the story and the mechanics of the player. From here we race rapidly to the end…


the final door


During a design lecture, Peter Field once spoke about a small but critical design element—the importance of the corridor leading up to a significant door. In the final segment of the hospital, the final door before the operating table is long and directed. This helps affirm to the player, unlike previous doors, that this must be the end.

Over the recent holiday, I finished The Legend of Zelda Ocarina of Time to experience one of the examples Peter Field mentions in his lecture—the final stairway to Ganon.


The power of parallels


As we head into the end of both Spring and the game itself, I wanted to mention one last bit I absolutely loved—the ending sequence in the hospital. Not only is the escape with Ellie done “on the stick” but it mirrors beautifully the heartbreaking first scenes of the game. As shown below, the game contains so many moments where the team uses consistent imagery throughout.


CONCLUSION


There is so much to learn when examining the thoughtfulness of games like The Last Of Us. It becomes exciting to see in what other ways developers choose to pair player mechanics with story, and how it builds an even stronger connection between the player and the characters. With masterful synergy between all departments, we begin to feel as the characters do.

Good level design really says something about the designer themselves
— Emilia Schatz

Thank you for reading. All credit the team, past and present, at Naughty Dog. I hope to explore, study and recreate more of my favorite levels in 2019.

For extra resources I strongly suggest the following:

Jon Hickenbottom